| Platinum | Tootie Marquez |
| Gold | Captain Billy Whizzbang's |
| Silver | Dave's Burger Barn |
| Bronze | Double R |
| Top Pick | Billy Bob's Burgers Bar & Grill |
| Top Pick | Christi's Hamburgers |
| Top Pick | Cupp's Drive Inn |
| Top Pick | Original Tommy's Hamburgers |
| Top Pick | Twisted Root Burger |
| Top Pick | Whataburger |