| Platinum | Schmaltz's Sandwich Shop |
| Gold | Jason's Deli |
| Silver | McAlister's Deli |
| Bronze | Toasted Yolk |
| Top Pick | Dave's Burger Barn |
| Top Pick | Demaria Tony Jr Bar-B-Que |
| Top Pick | Foxy's McGregor |
| Top Pick | Home Fries Cafe |
| Top Pick | Jimmy Johns |
| Top Pick | Revival Eastside Eatery |